Print Page | Close Window

Chainsaw opinions

Printed From: Unofficial Allis
Category: Other Topics
Forum Name: Shops, Barns, Varmints, and Trucks
Forum Description: anything you want to talk about except politics
URL: https://www.allischalmers.com/forum/forum_posts.asp?TID=164831
Printed Date: 19 Apr 2024 at 6:27pm
Software Version: Web Wiz Forums 11.10 - http://www.webwizforums.com


Topic: Chainsaw opinions
Posted By: DougG
Subject: Chainsaw opinions
Date Posted: 06 Oct 2019 at 8:42am
Looking to up grade chainsaws , have a 038 Stihl Farmboss that I've had for 30 years, it works good but someone said an 029 super will out cut it big time and a lot lighter too,, any experience with them? What's everyone using?



Replies:
Posted By: nella(Pa)
Date Posted: 06 Oct 2019 at 9:12am
Echo EV650, for 35 yrs. and still works good. It sawed a lot of wood and was backer over by my D17(dumb tractor), took 1 part for handle mount to repair.


Posted By: ac fleet
Date Posted: 06 Oct 2019 at 9:16am
I use Homelite SXL's have for years. ---The best brush saw is an Echo cs310 . I use an Echo cs 8000 on a sawmill attachment. Have several other oddballs tossed in, but they get the job done. ---General med. cutting I grab a Blue-Max. ---not a bad saw for the money. The sthil ms250 is on the de-barker. I had major starting problems with it and for a couple of years it sat in the junkpile.--drug it out and put a new chimina carb on it and now it starts/runs. former owner bought it new and never could get it started so he gave it to me.--I barely could start it so tossed it in the junk.


-------------
http://machinebuildersnetwork.com/


Posted By: JoeM(GA)
Date Posted: 06 Oct 2019 at 10:17am
I have an 029 and a 440 Magnum, love them, had the 29 for maybe 15-16 years, never had an issue

-------------
Allis Express North Georgia
41 WC,48 UC Cane,7-G's,
Ford 345C TLB


Posted By: DougG
Date Posted: 06 Oct 2019 at 1:14pm
Curious how much the 029 weighs,, spec on my 38 FB says 14 lbs and I believe it ! 20 years ago was no problem ,, pushing 50 now and Arthur Arthritus says differ !


Posted By: DMiller
Date Posted: 06 Oct 2019 at 1:31pm
I own a MS250, good saw for the money, mine (Knocking on wood) has never failed to start and run, also invested in a MS192, great little pruning saw. Have an OLD Poulan Countervibe 3400, has been THE best saw I ever owned, still starts and runs, smokes a lot these days as has HUNDREDS of hours on it, bought that one just at 35 years ago. Was when Hill Behan Lumber was in full business, they had it as a demo, would not run so I got it for $110 and tax, got it home had the chain guides in swapped where had chain pinched, swapped those was GREAT, two bars, who knows how many chains been on it, JUGS of chain lube.


Posted By: Dakota Dave
Date Posted: 06 Oct 2019 at 7:32pm
Still using and old Poulan 2300 CVA. I've had it since 1986 been throug a couple bars and many chains. Mostly I do trimming and take an ocasional tree down. It's a very light saw and suits my needs. If I needed a heavier saw I'd buy something else. I do have a husavarna but it's too heavy to be doing trimming above my head. My wife bought me a Remington weed wacker pole saw this year it's been great for cleaning up fence lines. Only has a 6" blade but you don't need much to keep the Russian olive branches trimmed back. And the long reach means I don't need to get into those thorny trees to trim.


Posted By: steve(ill)
Date Posted: 06 Oct 2019 at 7:36pm
MS250 here............ great saw.

-------------
Like them all, but love the "B"s.


Posted By: Dakota Dave
Date Posted: 06 Oct 2019 at 7:48pm
We've 2 MS 250's at the farm the old one works great the new saw not so much. It burns up chains it's been back to the dealer twice. For some reason it doesn't oil like it should. If I could find out who borrowed them I'll dissasembled and check the oiler.


Posted By: 200Tom1
Date Posted: 06 Oct 2019 at 7:56pm
I have a mid sized Echo. It has worn out several bars, numerous chains but it just keeps on running. I couldn't begin to count the truckloads of wood it has cut. After 20 + years of use I had to put a clutch in it. We were cutting hard wood that has been laying off the ground for years. The Echo dealer said it was totally unusual to replace a clutch on one.


Posted By: Tracy Martin TN
Date Posted: 06 Oct 2019 at 8:12pm
I like my Husqvarnas. Have a Homelite tophandle too. Great saws!

-------------
No greater gift than healthy grandkids!


Posted By: klinemar
Date Posted: 06 Oct 2019 at 8:50pm
Stihl O26 and 461 plus a Husqvarna 240 for triming. The O26 I bought new 28 years ago. Still runs and cuts but beginning to show it's age!


Posted By: Ted J
Date Posted: 06 Oct 2019 at 11:38pm
I've got a Husqvarna 141e that I've had for about 30 years or more.  It has never not started.  If it doesn't start on the second pull, then there is something wrong.  (Now that I've said that, it'll be a bear when I go to use it on Thursday.)
I just bought a Husqvarna 440e cause I got such a deal on it, I couldn't turn it down.

The Husqvarna is preferred by professionals and the Stihl is preferred by home owners.  That is a fact I found on the net when I was checking on my new saw.

All depends on what you are going to do with it.  Cut down BIG trees? Little trees and limbing?  The Husqvarna cuts faster, but the Stihl has more starting torque so it doesn't get stuck as easy.


-------------
"Allis-Express"
19?? WC / 1941 C / 1952 CA / 1956 WD45 / 1957 WD45 / 1958 D-17


Posted By: klinemar
Date Posted: 07 Oct 2019 at 7:50am
Ted, where did you find the fact that Husqvarna was preferred by Professionals over Stihl? My experience in talking with Loggers in this area is price and Dealer parts availability. When I took a trip last year visit my daughter in Alaska I attended a Fair in Haines Alaska and they had a Logging Competition. I couldn't see a Husqvarna Saw there! All Stihl. Both Stihl and Husky make Pro Saws and Homeowners Saws. Now with. John Deere selling Stihl a lot of the small dealers are upset. Same with Husky with TSC and Big Box marts selling Husky. Buyer beware in the Big Box marts as you don't find pro saws or anyone that knows anything about them. I have had Homelite, McCullough still have the Stihl and now Husky. The Husky I bought at TSC because it was cheap. It is not a Pro saw and I have to adjust the carburetor a lot. I don't see this saw lasting as long as a Pro saw in either Stihl or Husqvarna. Goes back to the old saying you get what you pay for!


Posted By: chaskaduo
Date Posted: 07 Oct 2019 at 8:04am
I got a McCulloch Eager Beaver 3.7"  610 16" Chainsaw, back in 93 and has had no problems ever starting or cutting. But like our old Allis's, parts aren't falling out of the trees. Wink  Should probly look for a parts one.
   

-------------
1938 B, 79 Dynamark 11/36 6spd, 95 Weed-Eater 16hp, 2010 Bolens 14hp


Posted By: nella(Pa)
Date Posted: 07 Oct 2019 at 8:55am
The logger that timbered off my woods used Stihl saws with a skip tooth chain on them.


Posted By: ac fleet
Date Posted: 07 Oct 2019 at 9:04am
Chas!!--I forgot the Eager Beaver 3.7.s, --I have a couple of them, still use them for some of the bigger stuff. --- We did firewood for 18 years and at that time used a new Homelite 8800 with a 36" bar to do the big stuff then the 3.7 for med and a baby beaver 2.0 for limbs. ---- later started getting unwanted saws and fixing them to run 235 Husky is a nice little saw, a bit heavier than the Echo 310. Blue Max is about the 235 weight, seams to cut faster as the chain speed is faster, which I don't care for. ---slower chain = more grunt, longer chain life, less heat build-up,etc. Poulans are ok too, I have several of them and use them too. ---I never was brand loyal  to anything! --- all brands have duds as well as great units. I seam to have the gotten only junk sthil ms 250! -- When I finally got to the problem and fixed that, now it starts pretty good, NOT as good as the Echos or homelites, or Husky, but now I can use it.


-------------
http://machinebuildersnetwork.com/


Posted By: 200 10and20
Date Posted: 07 Oct 2019 at 9:16am
Originally posted by DougG DougG wrote:

Looking to up grade chainsaws , have a 038 Stihl Farmboss that I've had for 30 years, it works good but someone said an 029 super will out cut it big time and a lot lighter too,, any experience with them? What's everyone using?
Doug buy the 029 hell of a saw I'm 64 and I love mine had it a couple years. Sweet saw don't buy a Husquvarna you would be better of with a axe!!


Posted By: Hubert (Ga)engine7
Date Posted: 07 Oct 2019 at 9:37am
Dealer service is the driving factor for me. I have two Stihl 028 Wood Boss models and love them, one survived a dive into 12 feet of water with not problems "stihl" going strong. And I was crazy enough back then to dive down into a tree top to find it. Confused Thinking of getting a 170 or 180 for limbing and light cutting. I need to try out the Jonsered 625 I traded a toy Poulan for but it has been way too hot here.

-------------
Just an old country boy saved by the grace of God.


Posted By: Ted J
Date Posted: 07 Oct 2019 at 10:03am
Originally posted by 200 10and20 200 10and20 wrote:

Doug buy the 029 hell of a saw I'm 64 and I love mine had it a couple years. Sweet saw don't buy a Husquvarna you would be better of with a axe!!
Joe, HOW MANY chainsaws have you owned?  How many trees have you cut down?  People have different opinions and Doug has asked for them.  WHY would you say that a Husqvarna is worse than an axe?  How many have you ever used??!!

I've used HUNDREDS of saws.  Yes, that is right HUNDREDS!!  On our little city of over 50,000, the fire department of which I was a member for over 30 years, used both for a while, but just about everyone would rather use the Husqvarna.  That is all we had on the rigs for the last 15 years or so.

How many fire department axes have you ever used Joe?  So, you opinion is welcome, but when you start spouting something that isn't true, you had better be prepared to back up anything you've stated.

Sorry to the rest of you guys, but up until now, everyone has stated which saw they like and the reasons for doing so.  No one, up until now, has said anything degrading about another manufacturer.  Give an educated opinion if you want.  Two years is not long enough to form an opinion.  I'm 70 and I've had mine for OVER 30 years.  Now THAT'S an educated opinion.

If you like your saw, say so.  If you don't like another that you have no experience with, don't say anything.


-------------
"Allis-Express"
19?? WC / 1941 C / 1952 CA / 1956 WD45 / 1957 WD45 / 1958 D-17


Posted By: Ted J
Date Posted: 07 Oct 2019 at 10:19am
Originally posted by klinemar klinemar wrote:

Ted, where did you find the fact that Husqvarna was preferred by Professionals over Stihl?
Mark, I found it here.

https://www.thebalancesmb.com/stihl-vs-husqvarna-chainsaws-2218119" rel="nofollow - https://www.thebalancesmb.com/stihl-vs-husqvarna-chainsaws-2218119


-------------
"Allis-Express"
19?? WC / 1941 C / 1952 CA / 1956 WD45 / 1957 WD45 / 1958 D-17


Posted By: 200 10and20
Date Posted: 07 Oct 2019 at 10:28am
Originally posted by Ted J Ted J wrote:

Originally posted by 200 10and20 200 10and20 wrote:

Doug buy the 029 hell of a saw I'm 64 and I love mine had it a couple years. Sweet saw don't buy a Husquvarna you would be better of with a axe!!
Joe, HOW MANY chainsaws have you owned?  How many trees have you cut down?  People have different opinions and Doug has asked for them.  WHY would you say that a Husqvarna is worse than an axe?  How many have you ever used??!!

I've used HUNDREDS of saws.  Yes, that is right HUNDREDS!!  On our little city of over 50,000, the fire department of which I was a member for over 30 years, used both for a while, but just about everyone would rather use the Husqvarna.  That is all we had on the rigs for the last 15 years or so.

How many fire department axes have you ever used Joe?  So, you opinion is welcome, but when you start spouting something that isn't true, you had better be prepared to back up anything you've stated.

Sorry to the rest of you guys, but up until now, everyone has stated which saw they like and the reasons for doing so.  No one, up until now, has said anything degrading about another manufacturer.  Give an educated opinion if you want.  Two years is not long enough to form an opinion.  I'm 70 and I've had mine for OVER 30 years.  Now THAT'S an educated opinion.

If you like your saw, say so.  If you don't like another that you have no experience with, don't say anything.
As usual you know everything!! I just gave my opinion like everyone else! Since you are the local know it all have at it!!!!! I have owned and used a lot of saws I wasn't talking about saws made 70 freaking years ago I was talking about a saw that is built today!!!!!!! What a company use to make and what they make today are all together different. You must have been awful busy using all those saws, the whole town must have burnt down while you was busy cutting the National Forest down!!ClapClapClapClapClap And you think you know everything about Allis Chalmers. WOW!!


Posted By: Tbone95
Date Posted: 07 Oct 2019 at 11:08am
Usually don't see this kind of ornery until February or so.


Posted By: 200 10and20
Date Posted: 07 Oct 2019 at 11:12am
Hey Tbone, I just gave my opinion like everyone else and apparently struck a nerve with Paul Bunyan.


Posted By: Ray54
Date Posted: 07 Oct 2019 at 11:21am
I have used 6 saws in 50 years of cutting. Use to be Homelite but they have been thrown under the bus till there name was no worth saving. Echo saws have served me well but are not the most powerfull for size. But I don't hurry much anymore, and like how Echo starts compared to others.



Now for Ted's beloved Huskis brother in law bought a small trimming saw. From a full time saw and small engine shop. They said it was the best,could of been if it would of started good. They fussed with a number of times,never got better. The other Husky was a big one with 40+ inches of bar. Was only 3 or 4 months old and the first time I used it the dang think seized up.It had cut the big stuff in 2 other big oaks. Same gas in 2 or 3 other saws,I did not mix it or fill it just holding it in the big stuff. They did rebuild it on warrenty and since the BIL is gone it is here,and we use it time to time. But always the back of my mind will this thing blow up again.


Posted By: Tbone95
Date Posted: 07 Oct 2019 at 11:38am
Originally posted by 200 10and20 200 10and20 wrote:


Hey Tbone, I just gave my opinion like everyone else and apparently struck a nerve with Paul Bunyan.

Well alrighty then.



Posted By: shameless dude
Date Posted: 07 Oct 2019 at 11:39am
started with Homelights (dad's), and thru the years had a few more, they were mostly always hard to start (lots of pulls). bought a new Echo and have had them about ever since. bought a new Poulan and ran it for a day, traded it off the next day for another new Echo. can't count how many semi loads of firewood or trimming I've done with the Echos. I've run Stihl's, they seem to run a lot higher RPM's than the Echos, oh and I did try a Huqusvarna in this bunch, still have it, but the carb needs work to stay running.


Posted By: Tbone95
Date Posted: 07 Oct 2019 at 2:45pm
Very very sad my image didn't show up.Unhappy
 
Anyway, in the waaaaayy back machine, dad had an old Poulan, the ones that were the color of a filing cabinet, weighed 100 pounds, ran about 10 RPM....LOLLOL  I remember him calling that thing some words I heard for the first time.  I'm a bit surprised to hear you guys praising Poulans.....I thought they had gone far downhill talking with the guys at work, but maybe not.
 
Then a buddy of his had a sharpening and saw work shop, set him up with a couple of McCullough saws.  Seemed.....average.  Then we got a  Deere, 80 EV, which was made by Echo.  Beast of a saw.  Would still be using it today, but the muffler is burned out and obsolete.  So it discharges right onto your hand and gets pretty warm in short order.
 
I have 2 MS 290's.  One is 10 years old, the other is 3 years old.  The older one has always been a cold blooded SOB, at least 10 pulls when it's been sitting.  Dealer swears there's nothing wrong with it.  Newer one starts on fewer pulls, but pulls harder.  It's got ever so slightly a bit more power than the older one, and I'm guessing by the feel it's in the compression (new vs. new that is).  Both great saws that I use a LOT.  18" bar on the new one, 16" on the older one.  Like to have something just a bit more powerful and maybe a 20 inch bar.  Me likes power.


Posted By: exSW
Date Posted: 07 Oct 2019 at 3:04pm
IF you have a good dealer get a Dolmar. Now known as Makita in the US. Built like a Stihl run like a Husky.


Posted By: Goose
Date Posted: 07 Oct 2019 at 3:06pm
I like my Husqvarnas. I have seven of them, ranging from 38 cc to 65 cc. They're easy to work on, light and well balanced. They've had many hours of use and still running strong.
 

-------------
"People are human beings, produced by the society in which they live. You encourage people by seeing the good in them." ~ Nelson Mandela


Posted By: DougG
Date Posted: 07 Oct 2019 at 4:11pm
Thanks for all opinions, just looked at a MS 251 Stihl and I'm thinking that maybe the one , but there was a 251 C and C BE , abbot sure on differences except price


Posted By: klinemar
Date Posted: 07 Oct 2019 at 4:43pm
Both Homelite and the Dealer down the road from me are gone. And I remember Elwyn telling me all chainsaws will cut wood unless you put the chain on backwards!


Posted By: FREEDGUY
Date Posted: 07 Oct 2019 at 5:56pm
Originally posted by Ted J Ted J wrote:

Originally posted by 200 10and20 200 10and20 wrote:

Doug buy the 029 hell of a saw I'm 64 and I love mine had it a couple years. Sweet saw don't buy a Husquvarna you would be better of with a axe!!
Joe, HOW MANY chainsaws have you owned?  How many trees have you cut down?  People have different opinions and Doug has asked for them.  WHY would you say that a Husqvarna is worse than an axe?  How many have you ever used??!!

I've used HUNDREDS of saws.  Yes, that is right HUNDREDS!!  On our little city of over 50,000, the fire department of which I was a member for over 30 years, used both for a while, but just about everyone would rather use the Husqvarna.  That is all we had on the rigs for the last 15 years or so.

How many fire department axes have you ever used Joe?  So, you opinion is welcome, but when you start spouting something that isn't true, you had better be prepared to back up anything you've stated.

Sorry to the rest of you guys, but up until now, everyone has stated which saw they like and the reasons for doing so.  No one, up until now, has said anything degrading about another manufacturer.  Give an educated opinion if you want.  Two years is not long enough to form an opinion.  I'm 70 and I've had mine for OVER 30 years.  Now THAT'S an educated opinion.

If you like your saw, say so.  If you don't like another that you have no experience with, don't say anything.
 
Sadly, I must know how in the !@#$ you could have run HUNDREDS of saws ?? Is this an accumilation of the SAME saw, variations of the SAME manufacturer ?? Amazes me to this day that the FIRST thing a f/d does is cut 4'x4' holes in a 2 story home roof for a skillet fire on the first floor LOL!!! Just wondering, and ECHO is the only brand to run IMO.


Posted By: steve(ill)
Date Posted: 07 Oct 2019 at 9:17pm
here is the "B" and "E" added to the Stihl
 
https://www.stihlusa.com/real-people-stihl-people/build-it/" rel="nofollow -


Posted By: Mactractor
Date Posted: 07 Oct 2019 at 9:43pm
Got a mixture of both Stihl and Husky as I would watch the loggers switch back and forth between the two brands as the models changed and they are still doing that. Heard a while back my dads old Pioneer is still running for its present owner.


Posted By: JC-WI
Date Posted: 08 Oct 2019 at 2:21am
Chainsaws... seems they all have a temperment of their own... some worse than others... and some better than others.
  Had pretty good luck with older Jonsereds, but don't know about the new ones. Actually liked the economy of the 52E cuts more than any other saw I had on a tank load of gas.
  Have Echo saws, but older models and they were good saws in the day, again, don't know about the new ones.
  Got a couple Stihl saws, used ones, the MS290 has been good, but the MS250 isn't as nice, might be the carb, or crank seals.
  Huskies? no Clue other than neighbor has to use ether on his to start the first time... but he is a little ruff on stuff too.
   I think I would like to try a new Echo... but then again, it would be nice if there was a hands on demonstration of all the saws to see what fits a person best... weight, balance, bar length, horse power, and torque... and if the thing feels flimsy.
 
Make sure the saw your buying isn't a cheapened version to sell cheap in a box store...
I read on a tag of a newer Poolon the life expectancy of it was 50 hours. ... So look close to see if the cylinder wall is steel or chromed or just aluminum, and if the saw has sleeved or ball bearing on the crank... and then look on the internet to see what others have to say about the model your looking at.
 

 Mark, I bought a saw at a pawn shop one time set up with the chain on backwards... and bought one that somebody had taken two chains to extend out for a long bar and one-half was riveted on backwards. Also bought one saw cheap because they said it was seized up... and got it outside and pulled the brake off and it fired right up. LOL you just never know.


-------------
He who says there is no evil has already deceived himself
The truth is the truth, sugar coated or not. Trawler II says, "Remember that."


Posted By: Pat the Plumber CIL
Date Posted: 08 Oct 2019 at 8:15am
Stihl , run canned gas and never have a problem getting one to start. Friend cuts firewood for a living. He runs canned gas every 3rd time he fills saw . Makes sure canned gas is in it when it sits . Canned stuff is pricey but stuff sure rins better with it. Long shelf life , no ethanol, and no mixing .

-------------
You only need to know 3 things to be a plumber;Crap rolls down hill,Hot is on the left and Don't bite your fingernails

1964 D-17 SIV 3 Pt.WF,1964 D-15 Ser II 3pt.WF ,1960 D-17 SI NF,1956 WD 45 WF.


Posted By: DMiller
Date Posted: 08 Oct 2019 at 8:39am
Wish they built saws as well as Brother In Laws old ProMac 1000, was a tad heavy but unstoppable with a chisel chain on a 28" bar. As my Poulan 3400, parts have pretty well disappeared for it too.


Posted By: Ray54
Date Posted: 08 Oct 2019 at 11:33am
As was said about each saw not just the model or the brand has a personality Wink I think explains alot.
Would explain how the BIL's little Hushy was a pain to start ether hot or cold.

The saw that most disappointed me was a Homelite Super XL that was not long before Homelite was bought out. Right on the cap it said mix less oil than the older ones used.I a lot of times still ran 32 to 1 rather than 40 or 50 to 1 as it went in other saws that still wanted 32 to 1. It and a cheapy Poulan both running when shut off, and next time I took them out seized. 

The little Echo has been the best starting saw ever. Been used on fence repair as much as wood cutting. Top handle so easy to hold corral board and cut. Perfect size to carry on barb wire fence work, or to brush out a tree.


Posted By: Sugarmaker
Date Posted: 08 Oct 2019 at 9:33pm
Folks,
I use the small Stihl saw I think its a 025 ish unit? I just pick them up and use them when needed. It has the old man start. Love that feature! Works good for me. I dont cut as much wood any more. Backed over it with the Ford Jubilee this spring. Picked it up out of the lawn and started it. That's good enough for me. 

Had a old Poulan in the way back machine 40 years ago! Was good till it got warm then no start. The old McCullough's cut a bunch of wood but had issues and were not much better. 

Did wear out one small Stihl years ago cutting pallets to make syrup. Blew out the case. Junked it after several attempts to repair.

Keep your chain sharp!
Regards,
 Chris


-------------
D17 1958 (NFE), WD45 1954 (NFE), WD 1952 (NFE), WD 1950 (WFE), Allis F-40 forklift, Allis CA, Allis D14, Ford Jubilee, Many IH Cub Cadets, 32 Ford Dump, 65 Comet.


Posted By: weiner
Date Posted: 09 Oct 2019 at 1:29pm
Do I dare mention a Jonsered?  I bought this back in the 70`s and still runs fine.  Cleaned the carburetor once.  I will admit this saw is not a saw I use a lot of,  may sit on the shelf for weeks and sometimes months without being started. I burned wood back in the 70`s and 80`s,  but not any more.

-------------
Real heros wear dogtags, not capes.


Posted By: Mactractor
Date Posted: 09 Oct 2019 at 2:27pm
Jonsered good saws, but after a time became a red and black Husky (they come outa the same factory)


Posted By: mdm1
Date Posted: 09 Oct 2019 at 3:45pm
I have an Echo, a Husky, a Mac, a Sears(Poulan) and one no one has mentioned. A Lombard Super Lightning!! The Loggers I have talked to use either Husky or Stihl. Husky's are a faster easier to use saw. They said the air intake was set up to keep the saw dust from the air cleaner. But they said buy either. Man give Ted a break. 

-------------
Everything is impossible until someone does it! WD45-trip loader 1947 c w/woods belly mower, 1939 B, #3 sickle mower 1944 B, 2 1948 G's. Misc other equipment that my wife calls JUNK!


Posted By: wjohn
Date Posted: 09 Oct 2019 at 9:07pm
If you get the MS 251 I will be curious what your thoughts are coming from an 038. The 038 is a good bit more powerful. I grew up running 028 Wood Bosses as we only heated with wood. Once I finished school and moved out I bought an MS 250 (almost identical to MS 251 power-wise). It's a great saw for me as I don't heat full-time with wood but I did notice the slight power difference when I cut into some 12" diameter honey locusts here.

I guess I'm a little worried you might not be getting a big enough saw, unless the 038 is overkill for what you do now.

Wish I could've found an 028 WB that I trusted but I just don't have faith that people on CL or FB have taken good enough care of a saw that old over the years. My MS 250 started after a few pulls this fall... Been sitting for a year, and the gas that was in it was 2 years old but at least it was ethanol-free 91 octane with the Stihl synthetic mix. My local Stihl dealer told me with the newer saws you don't want to keep pulling on full choke until you hear it fire, like I was used to with older saws. He said 3 pulls max and then flip it to half choke otherwise you'll flood it. I know some guys buy new saws and have a heck of a time starting them, and he seems to think that's a lot of the reason.


-------------
1939 B, 1940 B, 1941 WC, 1951 WD, 1952 CA, 1956 WD-45


Posted By: 1951WDNWWI
Date Posted: 09 Oct 2019 at 9:42pm
I have the MS 251.  Runs forever on a tank of gas.  To do the same job with the old Homelite 360 would take four tanks of gas.


Posted By: Ted J
Date Posted: 12 Oct 2019 at 3:12pm
Originally posted by 200 10and20 200 10and20 wrote:

As usual you know everything!! I just gave my opinion like everyone else! Since you are the local know it all have at it!!!!! I have owned and used a lot of saws I wasn't talking about saws made 70 freaking years ago I was talking about a saw that is built today!!!!!!! What a company use to make and what they make today are all together different. You must have been awful busy using all those saws, the whole town must have burnt down while you was busy cutting the National Forest down!! And you think you know everything about Allis Chalmers. WOW!!
Usually I just shake my head and forget about a blowhard like you seem to be.  But I had to get this off my chest.  Did I mention anything about a saw that was "70 freaking years" old?  NO, I did not.  Didn't I just STATE that I just bought a NEW saw and it's GREAT.  We have more trees in this town than just about anywhere in the nation.  You ever have a storm?  One that knocked down trees?  THAT is where I get most of my experience with saws in the last 50 years.  Previous to that, the ONLY heat we had at home was a wood stove.  Yes, I spent every winter cutting and splitting wood to stay warm.  That is what I consider experience.  I have NEVER said I know everything about Allis either.  I've stated that I have learned a lot from a lot of people on here.  These are facts.
If you can't be positive, shut up.  You don't have to be derogatory toward another person.  That just shows your ignorance, it just shows your insecurity.

Sorry guys, you that know me know I'm not that kind of person.  It's just that I've dealt with people like him most of my life and since I can't get fired for it now, I had to get it off my chest.  Sorry for the rant.


-------------
"Allis-Express"
19?? WC / 1941 C / 1952 CA / 1956 WD45 / 1957 WD45 / 1958 D-17


Posted By: chaskaduo
Date Posted: 12 Oct 2019 at 4:02pm
It's OK by me Ted. Hope you feel better. I know I would. Thumbs Up

-------------
1938 B, 79 Dynamark 11/36 6spd, 95 Weed-Eater 16hp, 2010 Bolens 14hp


Posted By: 200 10and20
Date Posted: 12 Oct 2019 at 4:03pm
Your story TEDDY get over it! Didn't say anything about you as a person, gave my opinion on a chainsaw and being it wasn't the one you liked you went on a rant about me. I see on another thread that you are also a plumbing expert WOW not only did you saw a hole in everyone's house in Wisconsin you also plumbed all of them. We have all been thru storms, we had a major ice storm up home in 78 if I would have known you was a PROFESSIONAL CHAINSAW OPERATOR back then you could have saved us a lot of work! Teddy I feel sorry for you nothing to do but insult people that have different chainsaws than you. So now since my opinion is different than yours you want to run your mouth about me. All your blabbering tells me what kind of person you are. All I can say is maybe you should check your DEPENDS because I think they are full of it.


Posted By: DMiller
Date Posted: 12 Oct 2019 at 4:08pm
From me too Ted, some times just need a rant.


Posted By: BuckSkin
Date Posted: 12 Oct 2019 at 5:16pm
Originally posted by DougG DougG wrote:

Looking to up grade chainsaws , have a 038 Stihl Farmboss that I've had for 30 years, it works good but someone said an 029 super will out cut it big time and a lot lighter too,, any experience with them? What's everyone using?


I use my old 029 Stihl Farm Boss almost daily.
I have a band-mill and use it extensively with that as well.
The guy I used to work for had several Husqvarna; they will cut, but everything about them -- at least the ones he had -- is flimsy and easy to break, such as the ON/OFF, throttle, and oiler buttons; they didn't withstand the occasional tree falling on them very well either.
Some people won't have anything else, so there you go.

I had not owned my 029 a week before I made some very important upgrades that made it a keeper.
I discarded the "safety" chain; .325 pitch if I remember correctly -- whatever is standard for them.
I got a different clutch housing with replaceable roller sprocket --- 3/8 pitch.
I discarded the 16" original bar and replaced it with a 20-inch Oregon PowerMatch
I use the NON-Safety old-timey Oregon chain -- 072 some-such-or-other.
When I bought all this stuff, I got several of everything and enough chains to last me for decades, which is why the various part-numbers don't come to the top of my head.

The change to 3/8 pitch chain made all the difference in the world.

If I had not made these modifications, I probably would not have kept the saw; as, all that "safety" crap turned a good saw into a useless toy.

Weight is NOT a factor in a chainsaw; if you can't swing a heavy saw for a few hours, you probably don't need to be using a light one either.

If I had it to do over, I probably would have went with the 039 Farm Boss of the same year.

I have always wanted an old-style 066, but have never had the extra money to buy one.

I hope this is of some use to you in your saw buying decision.

Around here, a person can get their nose bloodied or worse in a chainsaw brand discussion; people are sensitive about such things. 


Posted By: BuckSkin
Date Posted: 12 Oct 2019 at 5:32pm
Originally posted by Pat the Plumber CIL Pat the Plumber CIL wrote:

Stihl , run canned gas and never have a problem getting one to start. Friend cuts firewood for a living. He runs canned gas every 3rd time he fills saw . Makes sure canned gas is in it when it sits . Canned stuff is pricey but stuff sure rins better with it. Long shelf life , no ethanol, and no mixing .


I did not even know there was such a thing until I had a big pine limb to get into the electric transformer the other day and catch afire; that was a bit exciting. --- nothing I did; the wind did it.
When the power company guys came with the bucket-truck, they had five one-gallon cans of the stuff sitting in the back of the truck.
When I asked about it, they had no real better-or-worse answers; just that, the powers that be decided it was cheaper in the long run than having to make sure they had gas and oil-mix and always having to hunt down real gasoline and not the car stuff.
And, there was always the possibility that someone assumed the jug had the mix already in it when it did not.
They said the canned stuff was ever so much more convenient; and, with the canned stuff, there were no more costly mistakes.

For what it's worth, they use Stihl saws.
Curiously, several of the other bucket-truck contractors around here have hydraulic-powered saws; but, the power company does not use them.


Posted By: Robert Musgrave
Date Posted: 12 Oct 2019 at 5:36pm
X2 on the Dolmar (Makita)--PS-420 @42cc and 13,500 RPM w/bar and chain.  Fitted with 14" bar/chain.  I play back-up with son and son-in-law running big Makitas. New in 2012; replaced a Sachs-Dolmar Model 112 w/16" bar that was bought in 1985.  Awesome saw but servicing dealers are rare.  RLM


Posted By: BrianC
Date Posted: 12 Oct 2019 at 8:26pm
Pretty sure I read through the entire thread, but I didn't see it stated what the OP mainly uses his saw for. Probably NOT trunk trim at the Christmas tree farm.
I think one needs a 14-16" mini saw for cleanup in the tight areas. And a 20" or bigger for the good size work.
One thing I found out was that if the guide bar slot width is really worn, even a new chain will not cut. I guess the links just lean away too much and bounce off the wood.
Ethanol gas hasn't caused me problems lately.
The Husky 455 Rancher original 20" bar doesn't allow for enough chain tightening range.
Their bar with the replaceable tip allows use of more adjustment range.
Better fuel economy is a good thing, also maybe the saw stinks less.
I think they are all noisy, no one has a muffler breakthrough?
The saw is getting heavier for as the years roll on.

I can remember when we mixed 16:1 ratios. And fiddling with points. So fondly reminiscing about old saws is quaint, but I would look only at the new generation.
When they add cat converters, EGR and smog pumps, then another story.




Posted By: Mactractor
Date Posted: 13 Oct 2019 at 12:28am
Was told the new Stihl 362 pro thinning saw has electronic engine control, as does the Husky equivalent. That stopped me from buying one when I wanted a saw in that power to weight range after all the trouble I've had with electronic control in vehicles.


Posted By: BuckSkin
Date Posted: 13 Oct 2019 at 1:01am
Originally posted by Mactractor Mactractor wrote:

Was told the new Stihl 362 pro thinning saw has electronic engine control, as does the Husky equivalent. That stopped me from buying one when I wanted a saw in that power to weight range after all the trouble I've had with electronic control in vehicles.


My 80-yr-old mother bought a new self-propelled small push-mower, Briggs & Stratton engine with electric start, and it is electronic control; it also has a big sticker that says to never change the oil.
It started really easy and ran great for about two mowings and hasn't hit a lick since.
Nobody alive knows how to fix it.
I won't venture a guess as to the brand but it is red.


Posted By: fixer1958
Date Posted: 13 Oct 2019 at 7:26am
When the wife and I first moved to middle of nowhere the first year here I flat wore out a little Sears saw I acquired. Our primary heat is wood. That Christmas she bought me a Homelite Super XL 20" bar. She told me it was $550. I about had a stroke. She told me it had to stay in the garage and I can't keep it in the bedroom. That saw has cut a lot of firewood and 95% of it was hedge. Had to re jug twice because it doesn't really like ethanol. It's still going and looks nearly new and is the backup now.

Got a Stihl 291 farm boss couple of years ago. Good saw, little lighter. I'm happy with it.
Should have gotten a 20" bar instead of an 18". I'm about due for a new bar anyhow may do it then.
Have used Poulan and McCullough and wasn't that impressed.
Used a big ole Husky for awhile and it seemed pretty stout but hard to start.
Have a Homelite 360 that's a hell of a saw but once I get it started I'm to tired to cut wood.



Posted By: ocharry
Date Posted: 13 Oct 2019 at 10:56am
ya know i been reading this whole thread here and i have not read anything about saw grades

i like husqvarna saws,,,,well my old ones anyway,,,i have an old husky 65 i bought new back in the late 70's,,,,still using it,,,put a set of points and condenser,,spark plug fuel line and filter in it over the 40 years its been in the wood,,,and it has seen a lot of wood,,we used to sell fire wood,,,lots and lots of fire wood,,,my dad and brother and myself all burned wood,,,,i still do,,,my friend just gave me his husky 65 he bought new,,,,reason is the saw shop he uses would work on it,,,,parts are hard to find,,,,i brought it home put a carb kit and fuel line and filter in it ,,,fired right off....i just bought another one,,,husky 65,,,guy said it wont run,,,i wanted it for a parts saw,,,,got it home,,,has good compression so i put a carb kit and fuel line and filter in it,,,,,3 pulls and it fired up,,,so i guess im looking for another part saw,,,,cut some wood with it yesterday,,,it will sling some chips too,,,so now i have 3,,,yes they are heavy,,,but not to bad yet,,,but a good cut means that you got the CHAIN right,,,its all about the chain boys,,,good sharp means you dont have to push the saw through wood,,,if the chain is right it will pull its self through the wood,,,kinda like pull the trigger and the saw will fall through,,,,yep thats it,,,full chisel that is,,,not simi

when these OLD saws were being made,,,they were the PROFESSIONAL grade saws,,,IIRC i gave around $450 way back then for my new saw,,husky 65,,,,dad always had stihl saws....041av and before my husky i had a 041 farm boss ,,it was loud and vibrated your hands to sleep,,,,i hated that saw,,,i think they were the pro grade saws back then ,,,,they were expensive too

the older saws were designed to run in the 8-9000 rpm range,,,,the newer saws run in the 13-14000 rpm range and now i think they are putting rev limiter coils in them,,,,so the cant self destruct ,,,,but i guess you could lean one out and wreck it that way too,,,,anyway

the point is,,,,,i think they make saws for the home owner,,,,and then the rancher farmer and then the PRO saws,,,,each grade comes with a higher price tag,,,SO,,,i guess IF YOU buy a more expensive saw and you take care of it,,, it WILL take care of you,,,if you buy the cheapest saw you can find,,,,well in a year or so you may need another one

as for the bar wear,,,if you know how thick the drivers are and the slot is getting loose you can move up to the thicker driver,,,some drivers are .050...if the bare wears you could move up to a .058 thick driver,,,,or to a .063 driver,,,so there are ways to remedy little problems,,,,also most guys dont ever turn the bar over,,,and the bar does need addressed from time to time also,,,,just things to think about 

i would like to get a husky 372 saw some day,,,but if you look you will see a saw named HOLZFFORMA ,,,these guys make most of the replacement parts for the saw companies,,,now they make whole saws,,,they are blue,,,and they have a very attractive price,,,a real husky 372 pro saw is in the $8-1000 when new,,,,the same saw from holzfforma ,,(parts interchange exactly),,is $3-350,,,,,,,power to weight on this saw is just about perfection

i guess the old adage pay once,,,cry once still works

one other thing ,,,i do use the gas that is delivered here,,dont know if it has ethanol in it or not,,,i put stabilizer in the big tank when it gets here,,,PRI-G,,,not sta-bil,,,,,BUT i only put what i think i will use in the saw,,,if i put to little i can always add more,,,prolly ready for a little break anyway,,,,BUT i never put the saws away with fuel in them,,,,i ALWAYS run them dry,,,just a little trick to save you guys some headaches,,,,it works

ok,,,i guess thats my .02

ocharry




Posted By: DMiller
Date Posted: 13 Oct 2019 at 12:33pm
If looking to get a Commercial Grade Saw, check a site for Loggers, they will NOT buy a saw they cannot depend on no matter the price, and they generally do not buy cheap saws. If looking to go cheap then pays your money takes your chances, roll a Dice and grab any of them as all will cut wood.

Most of the non-commercial what are considered Hobby User saws are limited hours of service run them til they drop then pitch and buy another. Not about to lie and say any are better than any of the others as few are worth the cash anymore in limited use sales markets. Will generally run consistently for five to six years then throw problems that parts become an issue. Some will luck into great saws that seem to run forever and start like have starting motors, others are pull and pull and pull then run smooth as long as running.


Posted By: BuckSkin
Date Posted: 13 Oct 2019 at 12:40pm
I will say this about saw chains:
Just for the record, I am way under the poverty level; I live in the poorest state in the nation in the 3rd poorest county of that state; needless to say, I don't have money to throw around.
That being said, for most people, even professionals that use a saw for hours every day, it is a waste of time/money to hand-sharpen or pay someone to machine sharpen a chain.
I have hand-sharpened many a chain and I have taken them into town and paid to have them machine sharpened.
I finally figured out that my best option was to just swap on a new chain and be done with it.
I still always keep a sharp file handy; and, only when I have a dozen or more dull chains, I will leave them at the sharpening shop; but, I am saving neither time nor money; and, the saw never cuts as good.
The last batch of chains I ordered, Oregon Full-chisel 3/8 72DL, were $10.50 apiece; a quick EBay search shows them at around $16 now; a man's time ain't worth much if he can save money hand-sharpening a chain.


Posted By: BuckSkin
Date Posted: 13 Oct 2019 at 2:20pm
Originally posted by DMiller DMiller wrote:

others are pull and pull and pull


Like poor old Mel Gibson when he grabs that huge saw and we all think that nobody is going to mess with him now.............and then he pulls and pulls and pulls and it won't start...................the fact that it is so realistic is what makes it so humorous.
Had it have started on the first half-pull, it would not have been realistic.


Posted By: Dave H
Date Posted: 14 Oct 2019 at 6:57am
Dang Buckskin, I got this jig i clamp on the blade and file the chain with.  Works for me.

But, I gotta admit that a brand spanking new chain is fun to break in.  Wink




Posted By: BuckSkin
Date Posted: 14 Oct 2019 at 2:25pm
Originally posted by Dave H Dave H wrote:

Dang Buckskin, I got this jig i clamp on the blade and file the chain with.  Works for me.

But, I gotta admit that a brand spanking new chain is fun to break in.  Wink




I have one of those as well, Oregon brand, that I bought when I bought my first ever owned-by-me saw many years ago.
I think maybe it is still around here somewhere; I never threw anything away in my life; I do have a useless excuse of a brother that causes things to disappear though.

As for sharpening, I have decided on the same theory with my band-mill blades as well.
New ones are around twenty bucks.
The sharpen shop guy was charging nine bucks to sharpen one.
Run a new blade until it begins to dull; take it to the sharpen guy; go back to the sharpen guy to pick it up; it cuts okay for a while; metal fatigue has already caused cracks to develop in the gullets; before it gets dull the second time, it breaks at speed, whipping out like a mile-long sling-blade and taking out an expensive belt in the process.
I decided there was no future in that; it makes about as much sense as rotating your tires.


Posted By: Stan IL&TN
Date Posted: 14 Oct 2019 at 7:33pm
Well I can't add much here. Poulan used to make good saws as I had two of them....but not any more. Gave that last POS to my SIL and bought the Huskey Varnia saw. It's better but still not as good as the ms270 Stihl I have at the farm.

-------------
1957 WD45 dad's first AC

1968 one-seventy

1956 F40 Ferguson


Posted By: FREEDGUY
Date Posted: 31 Oct 2019 at 5:36pm
For the STIHL lovers, just saw a tv commercial for a bla bla FARMBOSS saw for x price and then the case would be 1/2 off ??? WTH ???!! IMO, that pos plastic case should be FREE with purchase Confused ?? The discounted case was supposedly a bargain at $25 Wacko


Posted By: klinemar
Date Posted: 31 Oct 2019 at 7:08pm
My first Stihl the 026 I had to buy the plastic scabbard as the cheap a## dealer wouldn't throw it in on the deal he also charged me sales tax as I argued it was for Farm use.Dealer said chain link fence was exempt but not chainsaws! The next Stihl saw a 461 dealer put the plastic scabbard on before I bought it and didn't charge me sales tax as he is a John Deere Dealer! The Echo I bought from Blain's Farm and Fleet has a scabbard and they didn't charge me sales tax!


Posted By: Walker
Date Posted: 03 Nov 2019 at 11:24pm
My opinion is they are loud and hard on yer back.


Posted By: Mactractor
Date Posted: 04 Nov 2019 at 12:33am
Back to the axe then. No starting troubles.


Posted By: Thad in AR.
Date Posted: 04 Nov 2019 at 5:20am
I have a couple small Stihl an 026 and a newer saw I can’t recall. Both been good. The 026 starting to smoke on start up and not idle due to old seals.
I have a poplin I use for nasty stuff like stump cutting and such.
I had a Stihl 031 for years but it walked off one day. I replaced it with a Husky 455 that has been a good saw but I’ve recently noticed it’s leaking bar oil as it sits. Made quite a mess in the shed. I haven’t taken time to mess with it.
The local pro shop closed this year. They were a good Stihl dealer.
Not sure where the loggers go now days.
I was given the 032 years ago. The original owner said it never cut one rick of wood and the saw looked like new. It would start and run perfect but wouldn’t make one cut without dying. I took it home and cleaned the carb got it running and same thing. I messed with it til dark. I was making a carb adjustment and saw faint sparks. I pulled it apart the next day and the coil wire was pinched between the cylinder and when it got hot would short out. Replaced the wire and had a good saw for 30 plus years.


Posted By: DaveKamp
Date Posted: 06 Nov 2019 at 3:10am
Hi, My name is Dave, and I have chainsaws... Disapprove

Chainsaw Anonymous Support Group:[Hi Dave!]

So... Right now... the smallest is either the Stihl MS170, or the Echo CS320... both with 14" bars but one of these days, I'm gonna get my paws on the Echo CS2511T with a 12".  The biggest is a Stihl MS880, and a 50" bar.

in between... lessee... there's at least 14 saws in there... and I use every darned one of 'em.  There's Stihl, Echo, Shindaiwa... and in the own-but-don't-use includes Craftsman, McCulloch, and Ryobi.

And those in the 'use' category, get used regularly.  The big ones don't get used as much, or for as long, because they're big, heavy, massive, beastly, and heavy.  The small ones get set aside when there's too much meat to chew for a small motor.

The one I use most frequently is the MS180C, I carry it in my service truck, and it has some stuff done that is an excellent example of circumstance, so I'll tell 'ya about it.

First of all, it was a powerless noisemaker when I got it from my Father In Law.  The only 'saving grace' of the unit (besides being free to me), was the tool-free easy-adjust chain mechanism... for a 14" bar, it's perfect for quickly cleaning up a yard mess with minimum hassle.  it doesn't have the 'mush pull' starter system (I don't particularly care for that, but won't snub people who do... it's just-not-me)   I gave it a good carb cleaning, nix'd the limiter caps, opened the exhaust, advanced the timing 4 degrees, tossed the .o43 'picco' bar and chain, and installed a 3/8 .050' in it's place, and was promptly informed by everyone that the MS180 would never pull it.

Well, it does... with vigorous authority.

I use the highest grade of non-ethanol gasoline (source of choice around here is 93 'recreactional fuel' at Kwik Trip), and I use Stihl Ultra oil at 40:1 in everything but the Shindaiwa (it needs a bit more).  I only mix up a gallon at-a-time, and when I'm done cutting, the fuel tanks get dumped out, and whatever's left in the small can goes in the D17.

Most of my other saws came to me from people who had 'problems' with them, and were discarding.  Most just needed to have the carb gone through, and what was left of the  fuel lines removed and replaced with new, as they were eaten away by ethanol.

Most chainsaws that are actually MADE by the company who branded them (meaning... not 'house brand' or 'big box' variant) will be well made, and well supported.  Stihl, Husky, Dolmar, Echo... they're all in this category.  Those rebranded to others, not so well supported after a fairly short time.   I know guys have liked Poulan, and the Homelite name is still around (but I think they're re-branded), Jonsered... I think is mostly made by Husky... and there's lesser-known names around like Solo, Tanaka, Efco that sometimes show up re-branded as Cub Cadet or John Deere.

It doesn't matter WHAT saw you have... if it's damaged and needs parts, or a service shop, and there's no shop around to do it, then it's not a worthwhile saw.

My worst experience with small engines wasn't on a chainsaw, but a weed trimmer... it was a Weed Eater (Poulan product), I bought it brand new, and it ran a total of four minutes before having fits, and would start, but not run, ever since.  I took it back to the True Value where I bought it, and learned precisely what they mean by "True Value". 

So every guy has his preference on brand.  I'll tell you that I like professional-grade saws, and it's generally NOT something that'd be found in a big-box store.  For those that say they 'cannot afford'... it's simply a matter of watching Craigslist or other local ads for something that turns up... and if you're handy with small engines, you'll wind up with oh... 20 too-many-saws in no time.

Small engine and chainsaw quality appears in build design-  you'll see different styles of crankcase casting techniques, and some designs... the cheaper ones, use a plastic crankcase that's in two pieces.  They tend to crack, which causes loss of seal, and they never run after that.  Single-piece crankcases are more expensive to make, cast out of magnesium or aluminum, they're heavier, but last longer, retain seals better.  When you pick up a saw, if it feels 'cheap', it probably isn't expected to serve you very long.  IF you see someone at the small engine shop that has a shelf full of OEM parts, and the same model/series has been for sale for several years, then most likely you're getting a better machine.

Older saws, regardless of manufacturer, tended to be lower speed.  As was noted above, 8500rpm was considered normal.  Modern saws are lighter, have less torque, but spin substantially faster.  With lower sprocket ratios, they'll still pull a good chain, but they'll pull it FASTER... which means it's stripping wood from the kerf faster, and you're spending less time bent-over while it works it's magic.  If you do some performance modification like what I noted above, it'll have more torque at that screamy speed, and your chain will eat wood faster.

The best saw, is the one that runs well, and has a fresh chain. The operator, however, makes the biggest difference, and sometimes it takes years to figure out why a guy has such bum luck.  It can come down to something as simple as process and order... like... after you fell the tree, sharpen the blade, and then, don't start cutting a tree from the bottom up... go from the top down.  Why?  Because the trunk is subject to wind-blown dirt and grit, which when you're felling or bucking a trunk, is an abrasive that's gobbling up the sharp edges of your chain.  By the time you've made a few trunk-biscuits, the blade is dull, and you're trying to work it through an easy limb.  go to a small saw with a razor-sharp blade that'll scream to the sky, and it'll reduce the small limbs to nothing in minutes.

Carry extra chains (get good ones, not cheap ones) and a file.  Touch up the teeth at every refuel.  Make sure the oiler is working every time you start it.  If your saw wants to cut in a circle, your filing technique (left side vs. right side) is not symmetrical.  Get the angle right.  Don't forget to check-and-correct the chain's depth-gauges every several filings.  Keep your chain adjusted properly.

Flip the bar over after a few chains.  but when you do, take a file to the outside edges of the bar- they develop burrs that snag on the wood as you're trying to cut.

Break the saw in propelry, and once that's done, Look up, and perform the mods.
Use the best fuel you can get.  Drain 'em when done.  Blow the crud out with compressed air, then clean up the air filter before putting 'em away.

Wear chaps, safety glasses, hearing protection, work gloves and good boots.  You'll meet plenty of guys who didn't, and they'll tell you the same thing.

There's an adage that says "You get what you pay for".  That's not always true, but... it's very infrequent that you get MORE than you pay for, and more frequent that you get much, much LESS.


-------------
Ten Amendments, Ten Commandments, and one Golden Rule solve most every problem. Citrus hand-cleaner with Pumice does the rest.


Posted By: klinemar
Date Posted: 06 Nov 2019 at 5:56am
Very well written,and sound advice! Thank you Dave!


Posted By: ihc pickups
Date Posted: 06 Nov 2019 at 8:14am
Very sound and very accurate advise Dave. I started cutting trees for the township when I was in high school. Had a homelite worse saw I ever had hard to start and run.
I have had nothing but Stihls I burn wood for heat. here in Eastern KS. a lot of that of that is hedge both for fence post and firewood.
 


-------------
Mike


Posted By: DaveKamp
Date Posted: 06 Nov 2019 at 10:38am
Like was mentioned by others earlier, there's some aspects of 'new' saws that define the obsolesence of old ones.  Having a 'collection' of old saws is cool, but cutting with them for an extended task is NOT.

Contact points.  Yeah, they work, and they're classic.  Up against the CDI system of modern saws?  No.  The CDI has it beat, as there's no moving parts, and by virtue of the operation the CDI has the ability to add a little retard to the timing at low speed, and SOME manufacturers actually take advantage of this to improve starting and idle.

Chain brake.  I have a couple old beasties that have no chain brake.  Though I have yet to hit myself with a bar, and though I've been working in situations where contact from a section of the tree became a nuisance tripping the brake, I prefer not to go without the chain brake, and the little bit of knuckle-protection it includes.  Aside from the safety intent (which may, or may not be worth anything in the event of a loss of control) I prefer to have the brake set anytime I need to set the saw down while running (to move a limb, etc.), as having the brake on assures the saw's idle will not spin up the chain into the dirt and damage the blade.

Btw... chainsaw blades last exactly 0.0392 seconds when contacting dirt... which is also why cutting the trunk of a tree should be done last, or at least... with a bigger saw, with a well-attended chain.  A friend of mine who spends lots of time bucking trunks of trees did make one observation- that his newer saw's higher blade speed did NOT last as long between sharpenings as his older, slow-speed engine.  His high-speed is a fairly recent Efco, and the older is a Stihl 041AV... the Efco is pulling the chain about 80% faster.  Side-by-side, the same chain type will need sharpening after fewer cuts on the faster, than the slower.  The key to a fast cutting saw, is a good blade... but there's times when slowing down gets the job done faster.  The big advantage to the 041AV, is that it's a heavy little piggie... you can almost set it on a trunk, put a brick on the gas pedal, and go get a cup of coffee, and it'll manage the cut all by itself.  (My MS880 is that way, too)

Bar adjustments-  I've seen some MISERABLE ideas for bar adjustments... and some really clever ones, but the one aspect that ruins ANY bar adjustment scheme, is when the mechanism is flimsy.  An unreliable bar adjuster ruins the whole saw.

Crankcase seal:  The #3 reason saws won't run well, is because of poor crankcase seals.  regardless of what people and books will say, 2 stroke engines are actually FOUR stroke engines, where two of the strokes occur at the SAME time.  The combustion chamber does it's two, while the BACK side of the piston provides the intake and exhaust scavenging.  There's crankshaft seals, a seal around the carb base, and seams where the cases come together, that if they ain't sealed tight, it won't breathe, REGARDLESS of compression.  Older saws used to have nice, big, open crankcases... and nowdays, there's barely enough room to get your fingers in there to work on things, and for good reason:  Just like combustion chamber volume has a high determination on compression ratio, the crankcase of a 2-stroke affects how the bottom side of the piston pulls in fuel/air, and pushes it up the bypass ports... it's like a reciprocating supercharger.  Having a small crankcase volume increases the compression ratio of the BOTTOM side, which increases the ability to push that charge up through the bypass ports.  This being said, a cheezy crankcase that doesn't seal, means you're holding a brick with a bar and blade.

Which leads to the other important part:  PARTS and SUPPORT.  Saws are NEEDY.  If the manufacturer doesn't exist... or it's a 3rd party (re-branded), you're NOT gonna get parts for it any time soon.  It may be one of the greatest saws in history, but when you're standing in the yard, and it's dead silent, the tree will NOT get cut.

Vibration suppression:  Old saws vibrate.  New saws vibrate too, but the handles are soft-mounted to make YOU last longer.  A chainsaw that cuts fast ain't worth a hoot if the geezer holding it can't keep a grip more'n 3 limbs without setting it down and getting feeling back in his mittens.  Same goes for noise control, and of course, weight.

The third being a special note here-  Not All Chainsaw Bars Are Equal... and also... Bars are CONSUMABLE ITEMS... like the blade, they wear... and they do NOT last forever.  They'll need to be flipped regularly, and when you do, file off the 'flare' that occurs on the bar, and take a scraper down the groove to get it clean.  Dirt eats the bar just like it does the blade, and you can't avoid it.  Now... there's steel bars, there's aluminum bars, and there's downright exotic bars.  These things are magical metal sandwiches, intended to control the flow of those saw teeth.  The outer sandwich is typically two plates of metal, with another plate on the inside, and the inner plate is exactly the size, plus just a smidgen thicker than the sprocket-spurs on the bottom of your saw blade.  That's how the GUAGE width of the chain blade is identified.  The 'picco' blade is 0.043"... while the more-typical size is '0.050.  There's bigger ones on bigger saws, and you can't just arbitrarily mix and match blades to bars... you have to mind that kerf.

On my MS180, the original bar had a 0.043 gauge... and my father in law was always cussing the saw's low power.  One of the major issues, was that he was using cheap bar oil, and cutting some funky mulberry bushes and sumac that was really sappy.  After cutting through all that gooey stuff (full of dirt, btw) he had a dull blade and a bar that was gunked full of sappy oily dirt.  He used cheap ethanol blend pump gas and generic oil, and always had an open-spout gas-can sitting on his garage shelf ready to go, when he used the saw twice a year....

CLEAN your saw.  Take the bar and chain off, dunk 'em in a parts washer, and scrub them out good... Blow all the sawdust out of the cylinder, flywheel, around the carb, and the chain brake/cover, chain adjuster, and oiler.  Sharpen the blade, file the bar, rinse it again, flip the bar, oil it, and reinstall it on a well-cleaned saw for storage.

Sharpening chains... I have a FAIRLY fancy electric sharpening grinder.  Once set up properly, and given proper technique, a guy can re-sharpen a double-fistful of chains in under an hour.  Push 'em too fast, the teeth overheat and lose temper.  Cut 'em assymetrically, and the blades will pull to one side and stall in the cut.  Fail to correct the depth gauges, and a razor-sharp blade will sit on the log and do nothing, making you look like a moron.  Taking off too much of the depth gauges will overload the saw, plug up the bar, and make you look like a moron... and to top it all off, if you do nothing, and just think they stay sharp forever, you'll stand there, with a screaming engine in hand, looking like a moron.  It's called a 'blade' for a reason, and they get dull after chewing cellulose-encapsulated dirt, so if you show up at a tree with intention of cutting for more than five minutes, and don't have a file or a spare chain, just take out the Sharpie and paint a bit M on your forehead, so people know why you're hiking back to the truck.

To figure out if your chain is dull or sharp, look down at your feet.  Is it being rapidly buried by big strinky hippie-dreadlock-hair, or oatmeal-lookin' ships?  Good- keep going.  Are you instead, getting dust in your eyes, and on your pants?  Sharpen your chain.  We're not here to make a pretty little sand-pile, son- we're here to look like we're wading in ground-zero of a Silly String concert.  When I cut big trunks, with the big saw I always want a second guy standing by with a steel leaf-rake to pull all the coily crap away, because when it's set right, I'm up to my knees in fluffy twisties halfway through the first verse of Lady Madonna.

Did I mention USE GOOD GAS?  Yeah, the pre-mixed 'saw gas' cans of the quart-variety are nice... the gross cost is something like $12.00 a gallon, but yeah, it's high quality, non ethanol, pre mixed and sealed up nice'n tight, so it stores and handles well... but if you're doing a big job, using top-notch gasoline with quality oil will get you good results, just don't leave any in a can more than a few days and expect it to stay good.

And before anyone starts a stink, the fact of chemistry, is that Ethanol is a caustic, Hygroscopic Carbohydrate... Hygroscopic means it absorbs moisture, and will draw it right out of the air.  It is caustic-  it chemically reacts with all sorts of other compounds, degrading them visciously.  As a Carbohydrate, not a Hydrocarbon, it doesn't actually 'mix' with gasoline... it is simply in SUSPENSION.  To see what that means, pour salt into a glass of water, and stir... it will dissolve.  Now pour pepper in water... it will NOT dissolve.  you can stir, and it'll be mixed around, but let it sit, it'll all find it's way back to the top.  Same happens with ethanol, but it winds up on the bottom... and heavily laden with water.  When you put this in a fuel tank, let it sit a few days, then start an engine, the first thing coming in... is water... then pure ethanol... then gasoline/oil mix.   Think of that when you're replacing fuel lines, picking crud out of carbeurators, and looking at scored up pistons and cylinders.  Using good fuel, EMPTYING the saw when you're done, and DISCARDING (repurposing) the unused premix when done, is KEY to good performance and long life.

And the most important point:  A guy who's really good with his small engines and saws, and is willing to invest the time and patience to do so, can make a crappy saw run great, and last forever.  A guy who's really bad with small engines and saws, can destroy the best one in the blink of an eye.

Most guys are somewhere in between.  The key, is to know which one you are, and figure out the key lessons, and having the best saw(S) you can, for the tasks YOU need to accomplish.  If you're planning on getting work done, don't be afraid to have more than one saw on hand, and having them of different sizes.  Don't waste your time and abuse a small saw by attempting large cuts... and don't buy a big saw with long bar and expect your back to be happy while reducing a bizillion 4" limbs into a pile.  Don't walk into a store with the intention of putting a long bar on a small machine.  A 50cc saw has NO business pulling a 28" bar.  A big bar requires a commensurately big engine.  While you CAN get away with smaller engines and big bars by using chains with fewer teeth (Skip-tooth)... the big bar has more teeth in the kerf, which means substantially more DRAG that the engine is wasting pulling through the bar, rather than eating wood. 


Overloading a saw is a loosing battle.

Besides, long bars are HEAVY.  Did I mention not all bars are equal? Fancy, expensive bars are usually made of laminations cut with CNC laser or waterjet.  Cheap saws from your big-box store are stamped by big worn-out presses.  Run your hands over the edges of two totally different quality bars, and you'll know why your big-box saw is so much cheaper.  Take a file to that stamped joke, and clean it up so the chain runs smooth... if the side plates are fairly flat, it'll do okay.  Really big bars get fancy in places you CANNOT see... namely... the middle of the sandwich.  See, that lamination isn't three flat plates... the inside one is  hollow in the middle... to reduce weight.  A 14" bar doesn't matter much, but a 30" bar puts LOTS of weight... both bar, AND chain... far from your body.  Making it LIGHT, means it isn't so ungodly heavy-feeling way back by the powerhead.

Btw... a big powerhead is usually heavy.  I don't remember how many POUNDS the MS880 is, but at 130ish cc, it's certainly more than I like to think about...  but it's practically unnoticed when there's a 50" bar with NINE FEET of .404 chain wrapped around it.  When you need to make a big cut, there's no replacement for displacement, and a bar that will reach all the way through (and my maples were too big for the 50!)

You can put a 16" bar on a 78cc saw.  Yep, it'd cut a concrete wall if you got the right blade, and are tough enough to survive it (ICS makes saws just for this).  If you're bucking hardwoods that're 14" diameter, you'll be a tornado of swarf and done in a hurry... and thank god, because that saw is heavy... and loud.  Hold my beer!

Did I mention how much I hate cutting up trees?  I can think of a dozen other things I'd rather do, than take a shower in ants, dirt, and 2-stroke oil... but worse I hate having a dead tree on my power lines, blocking my driveway, or obscuring my wife's lawn-mowing progress (this is particularly painful to my ears at night)...

There's a reason why I've got so many saws... they're like guitars...
  (You leave them in the dark for 20 minutes, and they multiply... all on their own)

I dunno Honey-  I thought there was just seven down there the other day... do you see nine? Hmmm... lemmie count again... How's the mower running? LOL


-------------
Ten Amendments, Ten Commandments, and one Golden Rule solve most every problem. Citrus hand-cleaner with Pumice does the rest.


Posted By: Dusty MI
Date Posted: 06 Nov 2019 at 11:19am
I have a Clinton that my dad bought new in the 50's. I used it up until '65, cutting fire wood to keep warm. Used it a couple of times over the years cutting a tree or two in the yard. When I used it I would have to clean the carb before it would start, ran when parked.
I now have a Remington 120 volt, no gas to mix and mess with, just a long cord.

Dusty 


-------------
917 H, '48 G, '65 D-10 series III "Allis Express"


Posted By: Dave H
Date Posted: 06 Nov 2019 at 5:39pm
YUhhh, i got a poulan that i bought new in mid 80's.

Ben running pump gas (E10 mostly) all its life with tech 2000 oil in the gas.

It is still running like new.  Hmmmmm  Confused


Posted By: DougG
Date Posted: 06 Nov 2019 at 7:03pm
Whats tech 2000 oil ?


Posted By: Stan IL&TN
Date Posted: 06 Nov 2019 at 7:25pm
I use a saw infrequently at our urban estate but did pull it out today. It was dirty from my last use and still had old gas in it but needed to be topped off so I pulled out one of those high dollar quart cans of fuel. Can was opened in 2014 as I wrote it on the can when opened. Filled her up and went to work.

All that said I agree with most of what you said Dave and most of it makes perfect sense but I have not seen muny issues with ethanol gas and for my line trimmers and leaf blower I mix up a gallon of fuel and use it all year long without issues.


-------------
1957 WD45 dad's first AC

1968 one-seventy

1956 F40 Ferguson


Posted By: nella(Pa)
Date Posted: 06 Nov 2019 at 7:51pm
Originally posted by Stan IL&TN Stan IL&TN wrote:

I use a saw infrequently at our urban estate but did pull it out today. It was dirty from my last use and still had old gas in it but needed to be topped off so I pulled out one of those high dollar quart cans of fuel. Can was opened in 2014 as I wrote it on the can when opened. Filled her up and went to work.

All that said I agree with most of what you said Dave and most of it makes perfect sense but I have not seen many issues with ethanol gas and for my line trimmers and leaf blower I mix up a gallon of fuel and use it all year long without issues.



Yes, there is too much made to do about gasoline and two cycle oil!Evil Smile


Posted By: BuckSkin
Date Posted: 07 Nov 2019 at 1:58am
Originally posted by Stan IL&TN Stan IL&TN wrote:

I mix up a gallon of fuel and use it all year long without issues.


I agree with most of what DaveKamp said; but, I will have to agree with you about the life of gas/mix.

I may use my Stihl for long hours and many continuous days and then it may sit for months with a full tank of gas/mix; it will fire off and run just as good on this months old gas as it does if I had used it just minutes ago.

As for Ethanol, I avoid it if at all possible; the local small engine wizard has shown me many times the effects of Ethanol in small engines and he says that Ethanol has made him more money and sold more small engine machines than anything else.
There is one place in our county that has a "recreational gas" pump; ever since I first heard of Ethanol, I have religiously made certain that any gas-burning engine I own gets the gas from that pump, be it the few old gas-burning trucks that I haven't yet converted to diesel, or the various small engines around the place.
A guy I know who mows many acres, weed-eats for miles, and uses chainsaws probably as often as any logger, buys all of his gas at the airport; when he is running an engine, it smells like that head-splitting poisonous smell at the go-cart track.
He swears by it and says his weed-eaters will start with the slightest nudge on the rope.

One idea I did come away with regarding dumping the saw tanks and emptying out the small mix cans immediately after use is --- I have for years religiously added 1-ounce per gallon of 2-cycle oil and 1-ounce per gallon of Marvel Mystery Oil to all of the 4-cycle gas engines around here; considering that, I may start dumping the saw gas into the mower gas can every once in a while and mix a fresh batch.

All that being said, I wish everything on the place was diesel and I had no reason to buy gasoline at all except maybe for cleaning paint brushes.


Posted By: Dave H
Date Posted: 07 Nov 2019 at 6:18am
Originally posted by DougG DougG wrote:

Whats tech 2000 oil ?


Tech 2000 or maybe it is 200 is Wally's label on its oil and filters.  Comes in the blue jug or box.


Posted By: DMiller
Date Posted: 07 Nov 2019 at 6:22am
Have shy'd away from the Tech line of oils, found they are recycled waste oil supplemented with strong additives to make it less aggressive on engines parts. Orscheln's sells a similar line where it does Meet specs for oil quality, just have seen all too much damage from those over the years to trust them.

No matter how well filtered and treated there are acids that build up in used oils from moisture contaminants, cannot remove all of it.


Posted By: nella(Pa)
Date Posted: 07 Nov 2019 at 8:31am
Originally posted by DMiller DMiller wrote:

Have shy'd away from the Tech line of oils, found they are recycled waste oil supplemented with strong additives to make it less aggressive on engines parts. Orscheln's sells a similar line where it does Meet specs for oil quality, just have seen all too much damage from those over the years to trust them.

No matter how well filtered and treated there are acids that build up in used oils from moisture contaminants, cannot remove all of it.


In the early 1950ies my father bought a 50 gal barrel of oil from a traveling sales man and it was exactly this type of oil.


Posted By: BuckSkin
Date Posted: 07 Nov 2019 at 8:49am
Originally posted by DMiller DMiller wrote:


No matter how well filtered and treated there are acids that build up in used oils from moisture contaminants, cannot remove all of it.


This has made me curious.
I am far from having any scientific knowledge, but I have read of how various acids can accumulate in engine oil; this got me to thinking.
I used to haul crude oil in those big old trucks that go "CCCHHHHH CCCHHHHHHH", from the well to the refinery.
Most of the oil I hauled was "Knox", whatever that means.
Many of the tanks had big salt-water separators almost as big as the tanks themselves; still yet, a lot of the crude would be as much as 30% water and who knows what else.
My question is:  how is this water contamination of crude oil different from water contamination of refined oil ?
Would not crude oil have the acids in it as well ?  


Posted By: BuckSkin
Date Posted: 07 Nov 2019 at 9:00am
To add to my previous post on re-refined oil: back in the 60s and 70s, we owned a full service filling station; one of our best sellers was "Red Diamond" re-refined oil; 25-cents/can if I remember correctly.
They had "Blue Diamond" as well; I can't recall what the difference was; I think one was maybe detergent and the other non-detergent.
We also had GRC Re-refined oil that was a bit more expensive for our more discerning customers (GRC = Gurley Refining Company).
In those days, it seems like there were many more vehicles on the road that absolutely drank oil; it was not at all unusual for someone's only means of transportation to "use" as much as two quarts per day or more, hence the popularity of the least expensive oil they could find.
If cars left big oily spots in parking lots like they did when I was a kid, the greenies would be up in arms.
Another big use for the re-refined oil was as bar-&-chain oil.



Print Page | Close Window

Forum Software by Web Wiz Forums® version 11.10 - http://www.webwizforums.com
Copyright ©2001-2017 Web Wiz Ltd. - https://www.webwiz.net